Ah, come on, Carter, that's too smart by half. "In Europe are restructuring talks really under way or is it just talk of restructuring?" So wrote our friend yesterday. Carter knows better. Neither is the correct question. It is, of course, "Who's talking?" It bothers the hell out of me because I don't know the answer because I don't know who SHOULD be talking.
We know this is a bank issue (too much Greek debt in too many Euro banks) but other than having a pretty good idea the insttutions are French and German I don't know the individual names. Sorry, I should, and I would certainly appreciate a breakdown from one of you out there if you have access to the information, but I don't. You see, this is pretty important because in the end the question is a very political one. It is not so simple as it is here where the banking system,while hardly immune to politics, is overseen by more or less a non-political governing entity in the day to day operation of the system. In Germany, for example, certain banks are for all intents and purposes extities of state governments and that makes them HIGHLY political. The problem in great measure is, I think, that despite ample warning and time to take action to protect themselves, certain banks, receiving cover from political entities did not do so and now stand in a very exposed position. It is therefore not only bank management that now has to play "cover my bum" but politicians as well and that makes for a very messy situation indeed. Before what needs to be done is done, the pols at the local level have to start talking and that hasn't happened yet...at least I don't think it has. If anybody knows better, please tell me. Carter?
In any case, we once again have witnessed the very strange contradiction between the U.S. banking system and the Euros in the coming to grips with a bad situation and the recognition of losses. Europe always dithers and the Americans are always prepared to, in some cases, throw the baby out with the bath water just to get rid of the problem. Witness Citigroup. You might remember that 3 years ago Citi essentially formed a "good bank, bad bank" structure and loaded into the latter all "non-strategic assets;" that means bum loans for all of you from East Moritches. In 3 years they have disposed of almost $600 Billion out of $900 Billion of assets. That, sportsfans, is a hell of a lot of assets to go away in that short period of time. If the Euros had done that we wouldn't be having this discussion. But they didn't. They never do. There's a psychological disparity here but of course there is also the depth, breadth and diversity in the U.S. capital markets that makes this possible. Which of course is another reason that I get so nervous when the folks in D.C start sceaming about mor regulation. Regulation is fine if put into place by people whose aim it is to improve the workings of free markets. Too often it is not. I bet there would be a number of people that might be buyers of Greece at, say, 50 if there was a market for that over there. There would be...wouldn't there...I mean...CARTER!
Moi? I have no comparative advantage here, that's why I read your blog! I do suspect this is sound and fury signifying nothing - Schauble doing what politicians do best - put their foot in their mouth. Merkel just delayed to get things past elections, and in any bet regarding the europeans one should probably take the OVER. German opposition to stress test rigor suggests no appetite for the banks to take the pain, not to mention Frau Schauble in NorthRhein Westphalia. Besides, systemic fun never starts in the spring - its always August.
ReplyDeleteIf the Landesbanks go, causing the Sparkassen to go, we will have an interesting German muni story!
Now tell me, how long can europe go without a functioning banking system in numerous countries before it affecrs growth?
Found this on Felix Salmon's blog:
ReplyDeleteGreek debt restructuring looks probable - Reuters poll
By Jonathan Cable
LONDON | Wed Apr 20, 2011 4:54pm BST
LONDON (Reuters) - Greece will have to restructure its debt in the next two years, say a strong majority of economists polled by Reuters -- despite firm denials from Athens and pleas not to do so from euro zone policymakers.
The poll, conducted this week, found 46 of 55 economists from across Europe saying Greece would have to restructure. The findings come almost a year after it took 110 billion euro bailout from the EU and International Monetary Fund.
Over half of the economists polled -- 24 out of 45 -- said it would be at least a year before Greece acted, while seven said six to 12 months. Ten said it would be within three and six months and just four opted for less than three months.
Thirty-eight economists said Greece would most likely seek to extend the maturity of its debt, while with 24 votes, lowering the interest rate on bonds was seen as the next most favourable restructuring option.
http://uk.reuters.com/article/2011/04/20/uk-greece-restructuring-poll-idUKTRE73J49520110420